May 16, 2024

A Guide for New Reddit Moderators

By David DeWald

Whether you’ve created a new subreddit or joined an existing mod team, this role comes with exciting opportunities and responsibilities. This guide will walk you through essential tips and best practices to help you succeed as a Reddit moderator.

1. Use Desktop for Effective Moderation

While it’s tempting to rely solely on mobile devices, desktop access is crucial for effective moderation. Here’s why:

  • Most customization tools are only available on desktop
  • You can’t easily update subreddit setting or AutoModerator from mobile
  • The indispensable r/toolbox extension is only available for desktop browsers

If you absolutely must use mobile, try accessing Reddit through your phone’s browser in desktop mode. However, for the best experience and full functionality, using a computer is highly recommended.

2. Design an Attractive Subreddit

Think of your subreddit as a party venue. You want it to look inviting and on-theme to encourage people to stay and participate. Here are some key elements to focus on:

  • Create a unique icon and header that reflect your subreddit’s purpose
  • Write a clear, engaging description of what your community is about
  • Customize the appearance using Reddit’s built-in tools
  • Consider adding menu tabs for easy navigation

Remember, first impressions matter. A well-designed subreddit signals to potential subscribers that your community is active and worth joining.

3. Seed Content Regularly

An empty subreddit is like an empty party – not very appealing. As the creator or moderator, it’s your responsibility to get the ball rolling:

  • Post relevant, high-quality content every day or every other day
  • Cross-post interesting content from related subreddits (with proper attribution)
  • Engage with early subscribers to encourage participation

Aim to have at least 1-2 pages of quality content before actively promoting your subreddit. This gives new visitors a clear idea of what to expect and encourages them to subscribe and contribute.

4. Implement Post and User Flairs

Flairs help organize content and allow users to express themselves:

  • Post flairs: Create categories for different types of content (e.g., “Discussion”, “News”, “Fanart”, …)
  • User flairs: Allow members to display information about themselves (e.g., expertise level, favorite character, location)

Flairs not only make navigation easier but also foster a sense of community and belonging among your subscribers.

Building relationships with similar subreddits can help grow your community:

  • Search for related subreddits and reach out to their moderators
  • Propose sidebar link exchanges or cross-promotion opportunities
  • Be polite and professional in your requests, and respect if they decline

Remember, other moderators are not obligated to help you, especially if your subreddit directly competes with theirs. Focus on how your community offers unique value.

6. Promote Your Subreddit Strategically

While promotion is important, it’s crucial to do it tastefully:

  • Use dedicated subreddits for promotion, like r/newreddits or r/promotereddit
  • Comment on relevant posts in other subreddits, mentioning your community when appropriate
  • Avoid spamming or excessive self-promotion, which can lead to bans

Quality content and engaged moderation will do more for long-term growth than aggressive promotion.

7. Be Cautious About Adding New Moderators

It’s tempting to quickly expand your mod team, but this can lead to problems:

  • Only add moderators when there’s a genuine need for more help
  • Choose individuals who are active, trustworthy, and aligned with your community’s vision
  • Start new mods with limited permissions and gradually increase their responsibilities

Remember, it’s easier to add moderators than to remove them, so choose wisely.

8. Set Clear Rules and Use AutoModerator

Establish clear, fair rules for your community and enforce them consistently:

  • Write comprehensive yet concise rules that address common issues
  • Use AutoModerator to automatically enforce some rules (e.g., removing posts from new accounts)
  • Be prepared to explain and defend your rules when users question them

AutoModerator can be a powerful tool for maintaining order, especially as your community grows. Take the time to learn its capabilities and implement useful configurations.

9. Engage with Your Community

Active, engaged moderators are key to a thriving subreddit:

  • Respond to modmail and user inquiries promptly and professionally
  • Participate in discussions and lead by example
  • Host regular events or discussions to keep the community active (e.g., weekly megathreads, AMAs)

Your involvement sets the tone for the entire community. Be the kind of moderator you’d want in a subreddit you enjoy.

10. Continuously Learn and Adapt

The world of Reddit moderation is always evolving:

  • Stay updated on Reddit’s policies and best practices
  • Join communities like r/modhelp and r/ModSupport for advice and updates
  • Be open to feedback from your community and willing to make changes

Remember, effective moderation is an ongoing process of learning and improvement.

Being a Reddit moderator can be a rewarding experience if approached with dedication and the right mindset. By following these guidelines and continuously learning, you’ll be well on your way to creating and nurturing a vibrant online community. Good luck on your moderation journey!

David DeWald

Building Online Communities since 1998 | Full Stack Community Professional | Host of Community Live

0 Comments